Decide your floor before the offer arrives. Emotion is expensive.
A £5 reduction can be sensible on one item and wipe out the worthwhile profit on another. Your offer floor should come from the item economics and your cash/stock strategy.
Start with your minimum acceptable net profit, then work backwards through acquisition cost, seller-paid fulfilment and percentage/fixed selling fees to calculate the minimum sale price.
Treat stock age separately: you may deliberately lower the required profit on stale stock to release cash, but make that a conscious rule rather than a reaction to a low offer.
Set three prices for every negotiable item.
List price
The public price based on market evidence and your speed/negotiation strategy.
Target price
The sale price you would be happy to achieve in normal conditions.
Floor price
The lowest price that still meets your minimum net-profit or clearance objective.
Check fee percentages at the floor
A percentage fee changes as the sale price changes. Use the fee model that applies to the marketplace/campaign.
Use stock age deliberately
A 180-day item may have a different commercial floor than a fresh in-demand listing — but record why.
Offers are business decisions, not judgements
A buyer offering 25% below your list price is not telling you what your work is worth. They are proposing a number. Counter, accept or decline against your plan and move on.
Beware round-number thinking
“I never take less than £20 profit” may be sensible for labour-intensive items and excessive for a five-minute £2-to-£15 flip. Create profit floors by category/work level if one number does not fit.
Cash recovery can be a valid objective
For dead stock, accepting a lower but still controlled return can free cash and space. Track clearance separately so you do not accidentally make low-margin buying your normal sourcing strategy.
Quick checklist
- Acquisition cost
- Expected selling fees
- Postage/packaging
- Ad fee if applicable
- Minimum profit target
- Stock age
- Clearance status
- Floor price written down
If you are doing maths while the buyer waits, your offer policy is not finished. Calculate the floor before listing.
Should I always accept an offer if it still makes profit?
No. Profit is one factor. Consider expected demand, stock age, selling speed, replacement opportunity and how much work/capital the item requires.
Should old stock have a lower offer floor?
It can, if releasing cash and space is valuable. Make it an explicit clearance rule rather than an emotional reaction.
How do I calculate a floor with percentage fees?
A calculator can solve the sale price required after percentage fees and fixed costs to leave your target net profit. Use the current fee structure for your account/marketplace.
Turn the advice into a repeatable workflow.
Track stock age, cost, sale price, profit and marketplace activity instead of trying to remember it all.